Before You Accept a Vendor's ROI Calculation, Validate the Assumptions.

SC Solutions ROI: move from theoretical savings estimates to a financial case you can defend.

Buy American Risk Assessment

SCx takes a vendor-agnostic approach to ROI. Results depend on operation size, current maturity and implementation quality, so every business case should rest on four elements built from your data.

  1. 1

    Equipment Investment

    Hardware, software, integration, facility modifications and infrastructure.

  2. 2

    Operating Economics

    Labor, maintenance, software subscriptions, support and expected utilization.

  3. 3

    Performance Validation

    Actual throughput requirements, peak capacity, productivity and downtime assumptions.

  4. 4

    Financial Comparison

    Payback, five-year total cost, sensitivity analysis and alternative scenarios.

Don't forget the labor gap, turnover & training

Hard-dollar ROI assumes you can hire and keep the people you need. For many operations, labor availability is the real driver behind automation, and it's the part a calculator understates.

What to validate by technology

Rather than publish generic percentage benchmarks, we list the inputs a credible business case must measure for each technology.

Autonomous Mobile Robots (AMR)

AMRs reduce non-value-added travel and cart movement so teams can focus on picking, replenishment and exception handling.

  • Reduce picker walking and manual cart movement
  • Add capacity without adding the same level of labor
  • Improve flow between storage, pick stations, receiving, and replenishment
  • Reduce dependence on forklifts for eligible material movement
  • Create a more consistent, measurable warehouse workflow
Model your AMR business case

Calculator results use your operating, labor and financial inputs and require final site validation.

Autonomous Tuggers

Tuggers move multi-cart trains on repeatable routes. The business case depends on whether freed transport hours become real payroll, overtime or avoided-hiring savings.

Model your tugger business case

Browser-only estimate with editable illustrative defaults. Nothing is saved.

Warehouse Management System (WMS)

Automates receiving, putaway, picking and shipping.

Validate

  • Current labor hours by process
  • Inventory and order accuracy baselines
  • Implementation and integration effort

Manufacturing Execution System (MES)

Real-time visibility into production, quality and machine performance.

Validate

  • Measured OEE and downtime baseline
  • Scrap and rework costs
  • Integration with business systems

Yard Management System (YMS)

Reduces trailer hunting and improves dock scheduling.

Validate

  • Detention charges from carrier invoices
  • Dock door wait and dwell time
  • Yard labor and moves per shift

Transportation Management System (TMS)

Supports Transportation Spend Management through carrier selection, load planning and freight audit.

Validate

  • Freight spend by mode and lane
  • Load utilization
  • Invoice audit findings

Voice Picking / Pick-to-Light

Frees workers from paper lists and scanning, aiming at speed and accuracy.

Validate

  • Current pick rate and error rate
  • Training time for new hires
  • Returns caused by picking errors

Our ROI Methodology

  1. 1Initial screening call to understand your operation, costs and the decision you face.
  2. 2Establish your measured baseline rather than relying on generic industry ranges.
  3. 3Model the full investment: hardware, software, integration, facility and support.
  4. 4Separate hard savings (labor, freight, detention) from softer benefits (accuracy, throughput).
  5. 5Compare options on equal footing, including alternatives and sensitivity scenarios.
  6. 6Review the model with your finance team before vendor commitments.

Engagements begin with an initial screening. A scoped financial evaluation, with fees agreed in advance, follows only if it makes sense. Learn more about Proposal & ROI Review.

Have SCx Review Your Automation Business Case

Send us the proposal or business case you are weighing. We start with an initial screening conversation.

Request a Proposal Review